In a small business, onboarding usually falls to the owner or the office manager, squeezed between everything else. That’s when steps get missed: a form that had a deadline, a laptop that isn’t ready, a new hire who spends the first morning waiting for someone to tell them what to do. A written checklist fixes most of it. Here is one, in the order things happen.
What should you do before the employee’s first day?
Most of onboarding can happen before the person walks in. Once the offer is accepted:
- Confirm the offer in writing. Job title, start date, pay rate and schedule, whether the role is hourly or salaried, and who they report to.
- Check the classification. Make sure the role is properly an employee rather than an independent contractor, and whether it’s exempt or non-exempt from overtime. Getting this wrong is expensive to fix later.
- Send the paperwork early. Tax forms, direct deposit details, an emergency contact form and your handbook can all be filled in before day one, so the first morning isn’t spent on forms.
- Set up their tools. Email account, system logins, keys or door codes, uniform, equipment, and a desk or work area that’s ready.
- Tell the team. Who is starting, when, and what they’ll be doing. Pick one person to be the new hire’s go-to for questions in the first weeks.
Which forms does a new employee need to fill out?
At the federal level, three items come up for almost every new hire.
- Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification. The employee completes Section 1 no later than their first day of work. You complete Section 2, after examining their identity and work authorization documents, within three business days of their first day. Keep each I-9 for three years after the hire date or one year after employment ends, whichever is later.
- Form W-4. The employee’s federal income tax withholding choices. Many states have their own withholding certificate as well.
- New-hire reporting. Employers must report each new hire to their state’s new-hire registry. Federal law sets a deadline of 20 days from the hire date, and some states require it sooner. Many payroll providers file this for you, so check whether yours does.
Depending on your business, you may also need to use E-Verify, which some states and federal contracts require, and enroll the employee in workers’ compensation coverage, which most states require for businesses with employees. Make sure the required federal and state workplace notices are posted, or shared electronically where that’s allowed.
What should happen on the first day?
The first day sets the tone. Aim for a person who goes home knowing what their job is, who they work with and what tomorrow looks like.
- A real welcome. Someone expecting them at the door, a quick tour, and introductions to the people they’ll work with most.
- The essentials. Where things are, when breaks are, how to clock in if they’re hourly, who to call if they’re sick, and how they’ll be paid and when.
- Forms that need the person there. Examine their I-9 documents, and collect anything they couldn’t complete in advance.
- Some real work. Even a small task gives a new hire something to finish and makes the job feel concrete.
- A short end-of-day check-in. Ask what was confusing, and explain the plan for the rest of the week.
How should you structure the first week?
Write a simple plan for the first five days: what they’ll learn, who they’ll shadow and what they’ll do on their own. Cover required training early, especially anything about safety, handling customer information or money. Hand over responsibility a piece at a time, and keep your go-to person available.
By the end of the week, the new hire should know the main tasks of the job, how their work is checked, and what good performance looks like in their first month.
What should the first 90 days look like?
Onboarding doesn’t end on Friday. Set two or three concrete goals for the first 30, 60 and 90 days, tied to the actual work, such as handling a set of tasks without help or learning a particular system. Then check in:
- Weekly for the first month. Fifteen minutes on what’s going well, what’s unclear and what they need.
- At 30, 60 and 90 days. A short review against the goals, with honest feedback in both directions.
If something isn’t working, these check-ins are where you find out early, while it’s still easy to fix with more training or clearer expectations. Write down what you discussed, and keep it in the employee’s file.
What records should you keep for each employee?
Keep one file per employee, with the offer letter, signed handbook acknowledgment, tax forms, pay rate changes, emergency contacts and performance notes. Federal law also requires payroll and hours records for non-exempt employees, and many states add their own retention periods.
Keep I-9 forms together in a separate file rather than in each personnel file. Many employers do this so that, if the forms are ever inspected, only the I-9s are handed over. Store anything with Social Security numbers, bank details or medical information securely, with access limited to the people who need it.
How do you make onboarding repeatable?
Turn this article into your own checklist, with an owner and a due date on each item: before day one, day one, first week, and the 30, 60 and 90-day check-ins. Use the same checklist for every hire, update it when you find a gap, and keep the completed copy in the employee’s file. Consistency matters for more than efficiency: treating every new hire the same way is fairer, and it’s easier to show you did if anyone ever asks.
How DomoDomu HR will fit
DomoDomu is building two HR products for small businesses, and neither is available yet. The HCM is planned to hold employee records and documents, onboarding checklists for new hires, time-off requests and balances, and who reports to whom. The ATS is planned to cover job posts and a careers page, an applicant pipeline, interview scheduling and feedback, and offers that hand a new hire over to the HCM.
That is the plan, not a feature list, and the scope may change before early access. Pricing will be published before launch. If you run HR yourself and want to hear when early access opens, join the waitlist.