A renewal is the cheapest lease you’ll ever sign. There’s no vacancy, no marketing, no turnover cleaning and no new tenant to screen. But renewals go wrong in predictable ways: the landlord remembers too late, the rent increase arrives with less notice than the law requires, or the lease quietly rolls into month-to-month on terms nobody wrote down. This guide walks through the decisions and the paperwork in the order they come up.
When should you start a lease renewal?
Put a reminder on your calendar about 120 days before each fixed-term lease ends, and plan to send the renewal offer about 60 to 90 days out. That window does three things for you.
- It covers notice rules. Many states and cities require written notice before a rent increase or before a lease ends without renewal, and some require more notice for larger increases or longer tenancies. Starting early means you’re inside the window wherever you are.
- It gives the tenant time to decide. A tenant who has two months to think is more likely to say yes than one who has two weeks and is already touring other places.
- It leaves time to re-rent. If the answer is no, you still have weeks to list the unit and line up the next tenant before move-out.
Also read your current lease before you do anything else. Some leases renew automatically, some require the tenant to give notice by a set date, and some say exactly what happens if the tenant stays past the end date. Those terms shape everything below.
How do you decide whether to renew?
Look at the last year of the tenancy rather than your impression of it. A short review is enough:
- Payment history. How many months were late, and did late fees get paid? Your lease ledger or rent roll answers this in a minute.
- Lease compliance. Unauthorized occupants or pets, noise complaints, or written violations you had to send.
- Condition of the unit. A routine inspection, with proper notice to the tenant, tells you whether the home is being looked after.
- Your own plans. If you intend to sell, renovate or move a family member in, decide now, because some places limit when you can decline to renew and require a stated reason.
Apply the same standards to every tenant. Fair housing laws cover renewals as well as new leases, and many states bar a landlord from raising the rent or refusing to renew because a tenant complained about repairs or reported a code violation. Writing down why you made each decision protects you if it’s ever questioned.
How much can you raise the rent at renewal?
Start with what comparable units nearby rent for today, then weigh it against what a vacancy would cost you. One empty month, plus cleaning, repairs and the time to find a new tenant, often costs more than a year of a slightly smaller increase. Many landlords keep a reliable tenant a little under market for exactly that reason.
Then check the legal limits. A few states and a number of cities cap how much rent can rise in a year or how often it can rise, and those caps often apply only to certain buildings. In places without a cap, the limit is usually the notice period rather than the amount. During a fixed term you generally can’t raise the rent unless the lease allows it, so the increase takes effect when the new term starts.
If you raise the rent, decide whether the security deposit changes too. Some states cap deposits as a multiple of monthly rent, so check the security deposit limits by state before you ask for more.
What should a renewal offer include?
Send it in writing, by whatever method your lease and local law accept for notices, and keep a copy. A good renewal offer is short and specific:
- The new term, with exact start and end dates, or the option to go month-to-month if you offer one.
- The new monthly rent and the date it takes effect.
- Any other changes: fees, utilities, pet terms, parking, or rules you’re adding.
- A reply deadline, and what happens if the tenant doesn’t answer by then.
- How to accept: sign the enclosed renewal, or reply so you can send it for signature.
Should you sign a new lease or a renewal addendum?
Both work. A renewal addendum is a one- or two-page document that extends the existing lease to a new end date and lists anything that changes, usually just the rent. It’s quick and keeps the original terms in force. A new lease makes sense when your lease form has changed since the tenant signed, when you’re adding or removing a tenant, or when the changes are big enough that one clean document is easier to read than the original plus amendments.
Either way, every adult on the lease signs, you sign, and everyone gets a copy. If a roommate is leaving and another is joining, treat the newcomer like any applicant and screen them with the same criteria you use for everyone; our guide to screening tenants consistently covers the process.
What happens if the tenant doesn’t reply?
Follow up once a week or two before your deadline. If the lease ends and the tenant stays without signing anything, the outcome depends on your lease and your state. In many states, accepting rent after the end date turns the tenancy into a month-to-month one on the old terms, which can mean the old rent until you give proper notice of a change. Avoid that by getting a clear yes or no before the end date.
If the tenant says no, or you decide not to renew, confirm the move-out date in writing and schedule a move-out walkthrough. Our move-in and move-out inspection checklist covers what to record so the deposit return is straightforward.
What should you update after a renewal is signed?
- The lease end date and the new rent in your records, so the first month at the new rent is billed correctly.
- Any autopay amount, if the tenant pays a fixed amount from their bank.
- The signed renewal, stored with the original lease where you and the tenant can both find it.
- A calendar reminder for the next renewal, about 120 days before the new end date.
How LandlordOS fits into a lease renewal
LandlordOS doesn’t have a renewal workflow; it handles the pieces around one. On every plan, the Reminders page flags fixed-term leases that are ending soon and can email the tenants. If you edit the existing lease’s dates and rent, LandlordOS changes only the upcoming rent charges on the lease ledger, so past months stay as they were; if you create a new lease instead, it sets up that lease’s rent charges when you save it. The signed renewal goes in the lease’s documents, where you can share it with the tenant in their portal.
On Standard ($25/mo) and Premium ($35/mo), you can send the renewal for e-signature: upload your own PDF, place the fields, and LandlordOS emails each signer, sends reminders and saves the signed copy with a certificate of completion. LandlordOS doesn’t include lease templates, so you bring your own renewal form. Every plan starts with a 14-day free trial.